True Crime

Cryptic Soup Pod

by Cryptic Soup Pod

Share this ranking Claiming needs an RSS feed. Contact us.

Listen on Apple Podcasts

Chart positions today · United States

Not on the United States charts we track today.

If you like Cryptic Soup Pod, try…

Cryptic Canticles presents Dracula

Latest episodes

The Dyatlov Pass Incident

May 8, 2025 · 2 hr 31 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss the well known case of “The Dyatlov Pass Incident”. Nine hikers went out into the Ural Mountains, attempting a level 3 hike, hoping…
The Watts Family Murder

May 1, 2025 · 1 hr 55 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss the sad story of the Watts family. Chris murdered his pregnant wife, Shan’ann, and their two children, Bella and Cece. Chris hoped…
Joanna Dennehy & the Peterborough Ditch Murders

April 24, 2025 · 1 hr 13 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss the life and crimes of Joanna / Joanne Dennehy. This woman was a wild example of someone who was ruthless, did not respect life, and…
Kai the Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker

April 17, 2025 · 1 hr 11 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss Caleb McGillvary (otherwise known as Kai the Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker” who took the internet by storm. We heard his story, the…
The "Mr. Cruel" Case

April 3, 2025 · 1 hr 46 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss one of Australia’s most notorious crimes, still unsolved to the date. Mr. Cruel was a particularly scary man who was breaking into…

Show 7 more episodesShow fewer episodes

Nicholas Barclay, the Imposter

March 20, 2025 · 1 hr 45 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about Nicholas Barclay, the 13-year-old child who went missing from San Antonia, Texas. The family was mourning the loss when…
The Angel's Landing Cult

March 13, 2025 · 1 hr 17 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee as they discuss Daniel Perez, the mysterious murder of Patricia Hughes, money appearing out of thin air, and how this might be just what you…
Tony Carleo aka the "Bellagio Bandit"

March 6, 2025 · 1 hr 36 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee as we discuss Anthony "Tony" Carleo, the man who (almost) pulled off one of Las Vegas’s Casino heists. Tony not only robbed the Suncoast Casino…
Wendigo

February 27, 2025 · 1 hr 21 min

This might be the funniest episode we've ever recorded... Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee as they discuss Wendigos and where the lore and legends came from, how to kill one…
Shani Louk

February 20, 2025 · 1 hr 7 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about the death of Shani Louk. Shani was attending the Nova Music Festival when she heard the Red Color go off. Shani had seconds to…
The McCarthy Massacre

February 6, 2025 · 1 hr 7 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee as they discuss the McCarthy Alaska Massacre that occurred one fateful day. It was a normal Tuesday Mail Day when Lou Hastings, a deeply…
The Transy Book Heist & American Animals

January 30, 2025 · 1 hr 2 min

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss the heist of Transylvania University in 2004. Four students created a plan to steal some rare books from the schools Special…

Full episode archive on Apple Podcasts →

About the show

Welcome to Cryptic Soup, an after-dark podcast filled with nightmares that haunt the daylight. Murders, crimes, cons, cryptids, and anything in between. Join the conversation and learn about what might be going bump in the night!